Nothing is more frustrating than pouring hours into a fundraiser—only to discover your group keeps just a fraction of the money. That’s where fundraiser profit margins come in.
Profit margins are the single most important factor when choosing a fundraiser. They reveal how much of every sale actually goes back to your school, sports team, or nonprofit. And the difference between 20% profit and 50% profit could be thousands of dollars.
In this guide, we’ll explain exactly what fundraiser profit margins are, how to calculate them, what affects them, and how to choose high profit fundraisers that maximize your group’s earnings.
Ready to get started? See how Midland’s fundraisers earn up to 50% profit.
A fundraiser profit margin is the percentage of money your group keeps after expenses.
Profit Margin = (Earnings – Costs) ÷ Earnings × 100
Sell $5,000 in cookie dough at 50% profit = $2,500 earned.
Sell $5,000 in coupon books at 30% profit = $1,500 earned.
That’s a $1,000 difference—without making a single extra sale.
Here’s a look at how common fundraising options compare:
| Fundraiser Type | Typical Profit Margin | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Candy Bars | 40–50% | Quick, affordable, easy to sell |
| Cookie Dough | Up to 50% | Always in demand, school favorite |
| Popcorn & Peanuts | 40–50% | Perfect for sports teams & groups |
| Candle Fundraiser | 40–45% | Seasonal gift favorite |
| Coupon Books | 20–30% | Lower return, harder to sell |
| Donation Drives | Up to 100% | No product cost, pledges only |
Pro Tip: A good fundraiser profit margin is 40–50% or higher. Anything less means you’re leaving money on the table.
Not all “high profit fundraisers” are what they seem. Watch out for:
Shipping & Handling Fees – Can quietly cut into profits.
Minimum Orders – Fall short and you may lose earnings.
Setup Costs – Some companies charge just to start.
Return Policies – Unsold inventory can cost your group.
With Midland, you’ll never pay upfront fees, and every program includes free catalogs, online stores, and prize incentives.
Here’s why Midland’s high profit fundraisers stand out:
| Fundraiser Type | Typical Margin | Midland Margin | Upfront Costs? | Online Store? | Free Catalogs? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cookie Dough | 30–40% | Up to 50% | No | Yes | Yes |
| Popcorn | 25–35% | 40–50% | No | Yes | Yes |
| Candles | 25–40% | 40–45% | No | Yes | Yes |
Midland consistently delivers higher profit margins with no hidden fees.
It’s not just about the percentage—it’s about time.
A cookie dough fundraiser with 20 kids × 20 sales each × $15 = $6,000 sales.
At 50% margin = $3,000 profit in ~10 hours.
A car wash fundraiser might bring in only $500 for the same time.
High profit fundraisers aren’t just more lucrative—they’re a smarter use of time.
❌ “All fundraisers earn about the same.”
→ Truth: Margins range from 20% to 100%. Choosing wisely matters.
❌ “The only way to make more is to sell more.”
→ Truth: Higher margins = bigger returns without extra sales.
❌ “Donation drives are always easier.”
→ Truth: While 100% profit looks great, product fundraisers often outperform in participation and excitement.
Elementary School in Ohio: $12,000 in cookie dough sales → $6,000 profit for new playground equipment.
High School Cheer Team: $9,500 raised in popcorn → covered uniforms & travel.
Nonprofit Donation Drive: 200 pledges raised $8,000 → 100% profit toward community outreach.
Want results like these? See how your group can earn thousands.
Schools – Field trips, classroom supplies, playgrounds.
Sports Teams – Uniforms, tournaments, equipment.
Nonprofits – Outreach programs, events, operating funds.
Churches & Community Groups – Youth programs, building funds, service projects.
Fall & Early Winter – Back-to-school and holidays = highest sales season.
Spring – Great for sports teams and graduation-related goals.
Summer – Perfect for camps and travel groups, though harder for schools.
Seasonal timing directly impacts your group’s profit margins.
Here’s your step-by-step playbook:
Choose a High-Profit Program – Focus on 40–50% margins.
Set Clear Goals – Share how funds will be used.
Boost Participation – Assign targets & use incentives.
Promote Online & Offline – Midland provides free online stores, brochures, and social templates.
Track Progress & Celebrate Wins – Recognize top sellers and milestones.
Need tools to make this easier? See how Midland’s free fundraising tools work.
Q: What’s the average profit margin for fundraisers?
A: Most fundraisers average 20–40% profit. Midland offers up to 50%.
Q: What fundraiser has the highest profit margin?
A: Donation and pledge drives can hit 100%. Among product fundraisers, cookie dough and popcorn are top at 40–50%.
Q: How do hidden fees affect fundraiser profit margins?
A: Fees like shipping, setup costs, and minimum orders shrink actual profit. Midland avoids them entirely.
Q: How do you calculate fundraiser profit?
A: Multiply sales by profit %. Example: $12,000 sales at 50% = $6,000 profit.
Q: What’s the easiest high profit fundraiser?
A: Cookie dough and popcorn—popular, affordable, and simple to sell both online and offline.
Every percentage point matters. The difference between 30% and 50% profit could double your earnings.
With Midland Fundraising, you’ll get:
Up to 50% profit
No upfront costs or hidden fees
Free catalogs, online stores & marketing tools
Don’t settle for slim returns. Start your high profit fundraiser today.
© Midland Fundraising 2025. All rights reserved.